9 Mistakes New Community Managers Make (and how to avoid them)

Imagine it is one year from now. You are still in the same place in your career. Maybe you have no role. Maybe you did not get a promotion. Maybe your pay has barely changed. The same problems remain.

You have worked hard all year, but nothing feels different. You still feel invisible. You feel like the last twelve months have been a waste of time and you are no closer to the career you want.

This is where many community managers find themselves. It is not because they are bad at what they do. It is because they keep making the same mistakes over and over.

Here are nine mistakes that quietly drain your career and how to avoid them so you can finally move forward.

1. Trying to Prove Your Worth by Doing Everything

It is tempting to work harder and harder, saying yes to everything in the hope that it will make you stand out. But when you try to do it all, you burn yourself out and make it harder to focus on the actions that will truly move your career forward.

Often, people copy what others are doing without considering that every audience is different. What works for someone else might not work for your community.

How to avoid it: Deeply understand your audience. Know their fears and desires so well that you could speak for them. Then connect their needs to the business goals and communicate that clearly to your boss. You will create real value without exhausting yourself.

2. Waiting for Permission to Lead

If you wait for someone to tell you what to do, you slow down your own growth. Whether you are already in a role or looking for one, you need to take action now.

Leadership is not about your title. It is about taking initiative, offering ideas, and showing you understand the value you bring.

How to avoid it: Proactively suggest ideas that align with business needs. Demonstrate that you think strategically, not just reactively.

3. Staying Stuck in Support Mode

Community managers are not just support staff. If all you talk about in meetings is the individual problems you solved for members, you will be pigeonholed into that role.

How to avoid it: Balance support work with strategic contributions. Share ideas, propose improvements, and show that you can create systems to help many people, not just one at a time.

4. Neglecting Your Professional Brand

You might be excellent at your work, but if no one outside your organisation knows about it, you limit your opportunities.

How to avoid it: Share at least one post every week on a platform like LinkedIn. Post ideas, insights, or examples of what you have achieved. Over time, this builds a visible track record and positions you as a thought leader.

5. Avoiding Data Because It Feels Intimidating

Tracking your results can be uncomfortable because it makes your impact visible and measurable. But without it, no one can see the true value you bring.

How to avoid it: Measure your results and share them. Saying “engagement increased by seventy percent” will always carry more weight than “the community is happy.”

6. Not Building Transferable Skills

It feels great to master a single platform, but platforms change. If all your skills are tied to one tool, your career is limited.

How to avoid it: Learn strategy, user experience, and research skills that apply anywhere. This makes you valuable no matter what tools your next role uses.

7. Measuring Success Only by Member Happiness

Making members happy is important, but it is not the only measure of success. Businesses need results that align with their goals.

How to avoid it: Maintain strong relationships with members, but always tie your work to measurable business outcomes. Balance audience needs with organisational goals.

8. Ignoring Burnout Until It Is Too Late

Burnout can creep up on you, especially when you take on too much in an effort to please everyone.

How to avoid it: Watch for early signs of burnout. If something is effective but unsustainable, look for ways to automate, delegate, or restructure it. Never let the community depend entirely on you to survive.

9. Forgetting to Plan Your Next Steps

If you do not know where you want to go, you will stay where you are.

How to avoid it: Regularly assess what you enjoy and where you want to grow. Share your goals with your manager and seek opportunities that align with them.

These nine mistakes hold many community managers back for years. But you can break the cycle by taking a more strategic approach, building your visibility, and focusing on results that matter to both your audience and your organisation.

💬 Join the Discord community to ask questions and get advice.